[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Thread Index
Date Index
Subject Index
Server's comments
- Subject: Server's comments
- Date: Sat, 17 Jun 2006 21:43:48 -0400
Walter & Group :
Hi Shane, Gordy and all,
I've just been reading the technical musings without remarking because it
would take so long to remark. Shane, virtually every detail you mention in
your paradigms of rod structural dynamics is bipolar (opposite of real
behavior). Don't be in despair because I suspect you have no real
expertise in Structural Dynamics. I'll just mention one or two things
to get you and anyone else in the right direction. Acceleration is easy
when the speed is low and takes great effort and energy as the center of mass of
object is put into motion. The idea of increasing acceleration at will is
simply unrealistic and would even be hard for a machine to produce let along a
human. It is better to think in terms of the torques which can be applied
to the rod -- a number of things effect the torque which can be applied to a rod
and it isn't long into the casting process when the torque can no longer be
increased and the rod begins unloading. The acceleration of the tip at RSP
is zero --i.e., tip speed at this instant is not changing while velocity
direction is changing so a minor acceleration is connected with direction
change. The acceleration of the tip is greatest at maximum rod deflection
which occurs long, long before rod straightening. As the rod straightens
the acceleration must decrease -- this occurs monotonically. That one
is very easy to understand and anyone with competency in basic college
physics can understand this statement. It is no different from the
behavior of a simple oscillator -- this behavior always
demonstrates accelerations proportional to spring deflection which are
comparable to the rod deflection. One last note is that from high
speed infrared photography images (and understanding rod structural dynamics)
about (my estimate) 25% of rod unloading occurs after the flyline is flying and
the loop begins forming. RSP is symbolic of the end of rod unloading
but the rod has stopped accelerating the bulk of the line earlier
(except for a little line near the tip which it is in fact trying to throw into
the ground and this accounts for the details of loop formation).
Referencing the high frame rate data posted in the past can give you a leg-up on
some of the physics associated with fly casting.
Regards, Server Sadik